Awards
American Soccer League (1921-1933)
- Champion 1921–1932
MLS Cup Playoffs
- MLS Cup 1996–2025
MLS Reserve League
- Champion 2005–2014
Major League Soccer
- Assistant Referee of the Year 2008–2014
- Best XI 1996–2014
- Coach of the Year 1996–2025
- Comeback Player of the Year 2000–2025
- Defender of the Year 1996–2025
- Fair Play Award 1997–2014
- Goalkeeper of the Year 1996–2025
- Humanitarian of the Year 1999–2014
- MVP 1996–2025
- Newcomer of the Year 2007–2025
- Referee of the Year 1997–2014
- Rookie of the Year 1996–2019
- Supporters' Shield 1996–2025
- Young Player of the Year 2020–2025
National Professional Soccer League
- Champion 1967
- MVP 1967
- Rookie of the Year 1967
National Women's Soccer League
- Best XI 2013–2014
- Champion 2013–2025
- Coach of the Year 2013–2025
- Defender of the Year 2013–2025
- Goalkeeper of the Year 2013–2025
- Golden Boot 2013–2025
- MVP 2013–2025
- Midfielder of the Year 2024–2025
- Rookie of the Year 2013–2025
- Shield 2013–2025
North American Soccer League
- All-Star Team 1968–1984
- Champion 1968–1984
- Coach of the Year 1972–1984
- MVP 1968–1984
- Rookie of the Year 1968–1984
United Soccer Association
- All-Star Team 1967
- Champion 1967
Women's Professional Soccer
- Champion 2009–2011
- Coach of the Year 2009–2011
- Defender of the Year 2009–2011
- Player of the Year 2009–2011
- Rookie of the Year 2010–2011
- Sportswoman of the Year 2009–2011
Women's United Soccer Association
- Champion 2001–2003
- Coach of the Year 2001–2003
- Defensive Player of the Year 2002
- Goalkeeper of the Year 2001–2003
- MVP 2001–2003
- Referee of the Year 2001–2003
- Rookie of the Year 2002–2003