| Joe Gaetjens |
Brookhattan |
— |
18 |
| Dick Roberts |
Kearny Scots |
— |
17 |
| Kropfelder |
Philadelphia Nationals |
— |
15 |
| Manteiga |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
12 |
| John O'Connell |
New York Americans |
— |
11 |
| Duke Nanoski |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
11 |
| Sasso |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
9 |
| Oliver |
Philadelphia Nationals |
— |
9 |
| Sokolowski |
Trenton Americans |
— |
9 |
| Owen |
Philadelphia Nationals |
— |
9 |
| Zelanko |
Trenton Americans |
— |
9 |
| Al Jennette |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
8 |
| Sullivan |
Philadelphia Nationals |
— |
8 |
| Lloyd Monsen |
New York Americans |
— |
7 |
| Bob Gormley |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
7 |
| Pito Villanon |
Brookhattan |
— |
6 |
| Jack Hynes |
New York Americans |
— |
6 |
| Capozzi |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
5 |
| Owen |
Trenton Americans |
— |
5 |
| McLaughlin |
Philadelphia Nationals |
— |
5 |
| Thompson |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
4 |
| Boulos |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
4 |
| Pietras |
Trenton Americans |
— |
4 |
| Ericson |
Brookhattan |
— |
4 |
| Carro |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
4 |
| Devlin |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
3 |
| McDougall |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
3 |
| Rochford |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
3 |
| Fernández |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
3 |
| Eisner |
New York Americans |
— |
3 |
| Sheppell |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
3 |
| Morgoglione |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
3 |
| John Calder |
Kearny Scots |
— |
3 |
| Santos |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
2 |
| Einstein |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
2 |
| Goldstein |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
2 |
| Miller |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
2 |
| Brandariz |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
2 |
| Ramos |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
2 |
| Joe Maca |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
2 |
| Sokolowski |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
2 |
| Campbell |
Kearny Scots |
— |
2 |
| Cahill |
Kearny Scots |
— |
2 |
| Sheppell |
Kearny Scots |
— |
2 |
| Brown |
Kearny Scots |
— |
2 |
| Flynn |
Kearny Scots |
— |
2 |
| McNab |
Kearny Scots |
— |
2 |
| Santos |
New York Americans |
— |
2 |
| António |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
2 |
| Zier |
Trenton Americans |
— |
2 |
| Malone |
Trenton Americans |
— |
2 |
| Zelanko |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
1 |
| Mathewson |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
1 |
| Woodside |
New York Americans |
— |
1 |
| Julie Chimileski |
Trenton Americans |
— |
1 |
| Menyes |
New York Americans |
— |
1 |
| Stark |
Kearny Celtic |
— |
1 |
| Rogus |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
1 |
| Werner Mieth |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
1 |
| Johnstone |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
1 |
| Carnecky |
Trenton Americans |
— |
1 |
| John Hughes |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
1 |
| Rolf Valtin |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
1 |
| Santour |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
1 |
| Antoni |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
1 |
| King |
Philadelphia German Americans |
— |
1 |
| McCann |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
1 |
| White |
Philadelphia Nationals |
— |
1 |
| García |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
1 |
| Woodside |
Brooklyn Hispano |
— |
1 |
| Iglesia |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
1 |
| Osowski |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
1 |
| Owens |
Philadelphia Nationals |
— |
1 |
| Dunn |
Philadelphia Nationals |
— |
1 |
| Watman |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
— |
1 |
| García |
Brookhattan |
— |
1 |
| Drake |
Trenton Americans |
— |
1 |
| Alcade |
Brookhattan |
— |
1 |
| Carro |
Brookhattan |
— |
1 |
| Logan |
Kearny Scots |
— |
1 |
| Waraski |
Trenton Americans |
— |
1 |
| Osmundson |
Kearny Scots |
— |
1 |
| Schutts |
Trenton Americans |
— |
1 |
| Knorheim |
Kearny Scots |
— |
1 |
| Santos |
Kearny Scots |
— |
1 |