https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn83030272/1894-10-12/ed-1/?sp=4

2 games sourced here

date competition season team score team venue referee attendance source page
Oct. 11, 1894 ALPF 1894 Brooklyn Bridegrooms 3 - 1 New York Giants (1894) Eastern Park W.H. Robertson 600 page
Oct. 11, 1894 ALPF 1894 Philadelphia Phillies 1 - 2 Washington Senators National Park, Washington DC James Richmond 1500 page