| Villa |
Querétaro FC |
— |
6 |
| Arroyo |
Club América |
— |
5 |
| Gordon |
LA Galaxy |
— |
5 |
| Gignac |
UANL |
— |
4 |
| Quintero |
Club América |
— |
4 |
| Djaniny |
Santos Laguna |
— |
4 |
| Ruiz |
San Francisco FC |
— |
3 |
| Peralta |
Club América |
— |
3 |
| Neagle |
Seattle Sounders |
— |
3 |
| Guerra |
Central FC |
— |
2 |
| Williams |
Montego Bay United |
— |
2 |
| Keane |
LA Galaxy |
— |
2 |
| Zamora |
UANL |
— |
2 |
| Bravo |
Santos Laguna |
— |
2 |
| Plata |
Real Salt Lake |
— |
2 |
| Elis |
CD Olimpia |
— |
2 |
| Opare |
D.C. United |
— |
2 |
| Doyle |
D.C. United |
— |
2 |
| Martínez |
Club América |
— |
2 |
| Dempsey |
Seattle Sounders |
— |
2 |
| Sinha |
Querétaro FC |
— |
2 |
| Hansen |
CS Herediano |
— |
2 |
| Escoboza |
Santos Laguna |
— |
2 |
| Zorilla |
San Francisco FC |
— |
2 |
| McCaulay |
Verdes |
— |
2 |
| Andino |
CD Motagua |
— |
2 |
| Mendoza |
Santos Laguna |
— |
2 |
| Rugamas |
CD Isidro Metapán |
— |
2 |
| Woodly |
CSD Municipal |
— |
2 |
| Damm |
UANL |
— |
1 |
| Dávila |
Santos Laguna |
— |
1 |
| Benedetto |
Club América |
— |
1 |
| Vega |
Saprissa |
— |
1 |
| Guzmán |
Saprissa |
— |
1 |
| Ramírez |
Saprissa |
— |
1 |
| Flores |
Saprissa |
— |
1 |
| Angulo |
Saprissa |
— |
1 |
| Orozco |
Santos Laguna |
— |
1 |
| Frederick |
W Connection |
— |
1 |
| Jones |
W Connection |
— |
1 |
| Colindres |
Saprissa |
— |
1 |
| Rentería |
Santos Laguna |
— |
1 |
| Rabello |
Santos Laguna |
— |
1 |
| Izquierdoz |
Santos Laguna |
— |
1 |
| Gonzalez |
Santos Laguna |
— |
1 |
| Escoe |
Saprissa |
— |
1 |
| Azofeifa |
CS Herediano |
— |
1 |
| Cunningham |
CS Herediano |
— |
1 |
| Briseno |
UANL |
— |
1 |
| Salinas |
CD Isidro Metapán |
— |
1 |
| Flores |
CD Isidro Metapán |
— |
1 |
| Torres |
UANL |
— |
1 |
| Uche |
UANL |
— |
1 |
| Milke |
Querétaro FC |
— |
1 |
| Rodríguez |
San Francisco FC |
— |
1 |
| Gutiérrez |
Querétaro FC |
— |
1 |
| Danilinho |
Querétaro FC |
— |
1 |
| Moran |
San Francisco FC |
— |
1 |
| Pinilla |
San Francisco FC |
— |
1 |
| Gil |
San Francisco FC |
— |
1 |
| Jimenez |
San Francisco FC |
— |
1 |
| Mendiola |
LA Galaxy |
— |
1 |
| Zardes |
LA Galaxy |
— |
1 |
| dos Santos |
LA Galaxy |
— |
1 |
| Maganto |
LA Galaxy |
— |
1 |
| Vayrynen |
LA Galaxy |
— |
1 |
| Lalin |
CSD Comunicaciones |
— |
1 |
| Plaza |
Central FC |
— |
1 |
| Blackburn |
CSD Comunicaciones |
— |
1 |
| Friberg |
Seattle Sounders |
— |
1 |
| Pablo Aguilar |
Club América |
— |
1 |
| Sambueza |
Club América |
— |
1 |
| F. Crisanto |
CD Motagua |
— |
1 |
| Hernandez |
CD Motagua |
— |
1 |
| Laureiro |
Deportivo Walter Ferretti |
— |
1 |
| Leguias |
Deportivo Walter Ferretti |
— |
1 |
| Israel Silva |
CD Motagua |
— |
1 |
| Parker |
Vancouver Whitecaps |
— |
1 |
| Alvarado |
Club América |
— |
1 |
| Evans |
Seattle Sounders |
— |
1 |
| Froese |
Vancouver Whitecaps |
— |
1 |
| Valdez |
Seattle Sounders |
— |
1 |
| Martínez |
CD Olimpia |
— |
1 |
| Zavaleta |
Santa Tecla FC |
— |
1 |
| Ruiz |
CSD Municipal |
— |
1 |
| Ricardinho |
Santa Tecla FC |
— |
1 |
| García |
Real Salt Lake |
— |
1 |
| Martínez |
Real Salt Lake |
— |
1 |
| Herrera |
Santa Tecla FC |
— |
1 |
| Olave |
Real Salt Lake |
— |
1 |
| Gonzalez |
Árabe Unido |
— |
1 |
| Addles |
Árabe Unido |
— |
1 |
| Small |
Árabe Unido |
— |
1 |
| Aguilar |
D.C. United |
— |
1 |
| Jeffrey |
D.C. United |
— |
1 |
| Woozencroft |
Montego Bay United |
— |
1 |
| Arrieta |
D.C. United |
— |
1 |
| Farfan |
D.C. United |
— |
1 |
| Ottey |
Montego Bay United |
— |
1 |
| Polo |
Árabe Unido |
— |
1 |
| Arroyo |
Árabe Unido |
— |
1 |
| Candelo |
Querétaro FC |
— |
1 |
| Benitez |
Querétaro FC |
— |
1 |
| Buscher |
D.C. United |
— |
1 |
| Sepúlveda |
Querétaro FC |
— |
1 |
| Andrade |
Club América |
— |
1 |
| Rivas |
UANL |
— |
1 |