Olthaus game log
| cmp | date | team | r | score | vs | g | a | minutes | venue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ASL2 | Nov. 2, 1947 | Brooklyn Hispano | 4 - 7 | New York Americans | 1 | — | — | New York, NY | |
| ASL2 | April 23, 1939 | Philadelphia German Americans | 6 - 4 | Kearny Scots | 0 | — | 90 | Scots Field | |
| USOC | April 15, 1939 | Brooklyn Celtic | 2 - 0 | Philadelphia German Americans | 0 | — | 90 | Yellow Jacket Stadium, Philadelphia, PA |