Games
| date |
season |
team |
score |
team |
venue |
referee |
attendance |
sources |
| April 27, 1958 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
3 - 4 |
Philadelphia German Americans |
Zerega Oval |
|
— |
1 |
| April 20, 1958 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
2 - 4 |
Newark Portuguese |
Zerega Oval |
|
— |
1 |
| April 13, 1958 |
1957-1958 |
Brookhattan |
2 - 1 |
Brooklyn Italians |
Zerega Oval |
|
— |
1 |
| March 16, 1958 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
np |
Ludlow Lusitano |
Franklin Park, Ludlow, MA |
|
— |
1 |
| March 9, 1958 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
2 - 3 |
Fall River SC |
Lafayette High School, Brooklyn, NY |
|
— |
1 |
| March 2, 1958 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
np |
Philadelphia German Americans |
Brooklyn Soccer Field |
|
— |
1 |
| Feb. 9, 1958 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
0 - 7 |
Philadelphia Ukrainians |
|
|
— |
1 |
| Jan. 12, 1958 |
1957-1958 |
Baltimore Pompei |
7 - 3 |
Brooklyn Italians |
Kahler Park |
|
— |
1 |
| Dec. 15, 1957 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
np |
Lusitano |
Franklin Park, Ludlow, MA |
|
— |
1 |
| Nov. 17, 1957 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
v |
Philadelphia Ukrainians |
Lafayette High School, Brooklyn, NY |
|
— |
1 |
| Oct. 20, 1957 |
1957-1958 |
Baltimore Pompei |
0 - 3 |
Brooklyn Italians |
Baltimore, MD |
|
— |
1 |
| Oct. 13, 1957 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
0 - 4 |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
Lafayette High School Field |
|
— |
1 |
| Sept. 15, 1957 |
1957-1958 |
Brooklyn Italians |
v |
Hakoah (ASL2) |
Zerega Oval |
|
— |
1 |