| Oct. 15, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Harrison Alley Boys |
3 - 1 |
Splitdorf FC |
Clark ONT Field |
|
— |
1 |
| Oct. 28, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Bethlehem Steel |
6 - 1 |
Philadelphia Hibernian |
Steel Field |
George Allen |
— |
2 |
| Oct. 29, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Clan MacDuff |
0 - 1 |
New York Field Club |
Harlem Oval |
|
— |
1 |
| Oct. 29, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Babcock & Wilcox |
4 - 1 |
Greenpoint FC |
Bayonne, NJ |
|
— |
1 |
| Nov. 12, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Bay Ridge FC |
2 - 1 |
Kearny Celtic |
Hawthorne Field |
|
— |
2 |
| Nov. 26, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Bridgeport City |
1 - 3 |
New York Field Club |
Harlem Oval |
|
2000 |
1 |
| Dec. 3, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Brooklyn Celtic |
6 - 0 |
Falls Cricket and Football Club |
Harlem Oval |
|
— |
2 |
| Dec. 3, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Continentals |
2 - 1 |
Schenectady General Electric |
Lenox Oval |
|
— |
2 |
| Dec. 3, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Clan MacDonald |
0 - 1 |
Paterson Dublins |
Hawthorne Field |
|
— |
2 |
| Dec. 9, 1916 |
1916-1917 |
|
Bethlehem Steel |
2 - 0 |
Disston |
Steel Field |
Andrew Laurie |
— |
1 |
| Jan. 21, 1917 |
1916-1917 |
3 |
Clan MacDonald |
4 - 1 |
Continentals |
Lenox Oval |
|
— |
1 |
| Jan. 28, 1917 |
1916-1917 |
3 |
Bethlehem Steel |
2 - 1 |
New York Field Club |
Harlem Oval |
T. Cunningham |
5000 |
2 |
| March 10, 1917 |
1916-1917 |
sf |
Brooklyn Celtic |
v |
West Hudson AA |
|
|
— |
1 |
| March 11, 1917 |
1916-1917 |
sf |
Bethlehem Steel |
5 - 0 |
Clan MacDonald |
East Newark, NJ |
Andrew Lawrie |
— |
2 |
| May 13, 1917 |
1916-1917 |
f |
Bethlehem Steel |
7 - 0 |
West Hudson AA |
Weidenmayer's Park |
Charles Creighton |
5000 |
1 |