USL Second Division | Players' Shield

season	recipient
2011	Orlando City SC
2012	Orlando City SC
2013	Richmond Kickers
2014	Orlando City SC
2015	Rochester Rhinos
2016	New York Red Bulls II
2017	Real Monarchs SLC
2018	FC Cincinnati
2019	Phoenix Rising FC
2020	Reno 1868 FC
2021	Tampa Bay Rowdies
2022	San Antonio FC
2023	Pittsburgh Riverhounds
2024	Louisville City FC
2025	Louisville City FC