- 2/16/1890 +
Feb. 16, 1890 F 1889-1890 Christian Brothers College 0 - 1 St. Louis Pastimes 1
Feb. 16, 1890 F 1889-1890 New York Nonpareils 2 - 4 New York Thistles New York Nonpareils 400 1
Feb. 16, 1890 F 1889-1890 Pawtucket Free Wanderers 5 - 2 Thornton Rovers Dexter Street Grounds 1
Feb. 16, 1890 F 1889-1890 St. Louis Hibernians 0 - 1 St. Louis Kensingtons 1
Feb. 16, 1890 F 1889-1890 St. Louis Olympics 1 - 1 St. Louis Shamrocks 1