Nov. 16, 1909 F 1909 Crescent A.C. 1 - 6 Pilgrims Brooklyn, NY Harlan 450 2
Nov. 14, 1909 F 1909 New York Amateur League 2 - 2 Pilgrims Meyerrose Park J. Evans 1200 2
Nov. 13, 1909 F 1909 Fall River Rovers 2 - 1 Pilgrims Fall River, MA 3965 2
Nov. 10, 1909 F 1909 Fall River Rovers 1 - 1 Pilgrims Fall River, MA 2821 2
Nov. 6, 1909 F 1909 Pennsylvania League Stars 0 - 9 Pilgrims Philadelphia, PA 4586 1
Nov. 4, 1909 F 1909 Haverford College 1 - 0 Pilgrims Philadelphia, PA 1077 2
Nov. 2, 1909 F 1909 Philadelphia Cricket Clubs Stars 0 - 3 Pilgrims Philadelphia, PA 800 1
Oct. 31, 1909 F 1909 Pilgrims 12 - 0 St. Leo's St. Louis, MO 4300 2
Oct. 30, 1909 F 1909 Pilgrims 4 - 0 Western All-Stars St. Louis, MO 1200 2
Oct. 26, 1909 F 1909 Coal City Maroons 0 - 0 Pilgrims Coal City, IL 450 1
Oct. 24, 1909 F 1909 Chicago XI 0 - 3 Pilgrims Chicago, IL 6000 2
Oct. 23, 1909 F 1909 Hyde Park Blues 2 - 8 Pilgrims Chicago, IL 700 1
Oct. 20, 1909 F 1909 Gillespie Thistle 1 - 1 Pilgrims Gillespie, IL 500 1
Oct. 17, 1909 F 1909 Pilgrims 10 - 1 St. Teresas St. Louis, MO 2057 1
Oct. 16, 1909 F 1909 Blue Bells 0 - 5 Pilgrims St. Louis, MO 1600 1
Oct. 14, 1909 F 1909 Cincinnati XI 0 - 9 Pilgrims Cincinnati, OH 1000 1
Oct. 12, 1909 F 1909 Pilgrims 2 - 1 Trenton XI Wilbur Baseball Grounds, Trenton, NJ C. Coopland 500 2
Oct. 10, 1909 F 1909 Kearny Scots 0 - 5 Pilgrims Newark Baseball Grounds, Newark, NJ 5000 2
Oct. 9, 1909 F 1909 Baltimore XI 0 - 11 Pilgrims Baltimore, MD 900 2
Oct. 7, 1909 F 1909 Mount Washington 0 - 14 Pilgrims Baltimore, MD 700 2
Oct. 5, 1909 F 1909 Pilgrims 13 - 0 Sons of St. George Baltimore, MD 400 2
Oct. 2, 1909 F 1909 New York XI 0 - 4 Pilgrims Staten Island Cricket Club W. Stanser 2000 2
Oct. 24, 1905 F 1905 Pilgrims 10 - 0 University of Pennsylvania Franklin Field P. Bishop 5000 2
Oct. 21, 1905 F 1905 New York XI 1 - 7 Pilgrims Polo Grounds Milton 3000 2
Oct. 16, 1905 F 1905 Boston XI 0 - 5 Pilgrims South Ends Grounds, Boston, MA Pollock 2
Oct. 14, 1905 F 1905 Fall River XI 3 - 4 Pilgrims Bedford Street Athletic Grounds 7000 2
Oct. 7, 1905 F 1905 Philadelphia XI 0 - 5 Pilgrims Philadelphia, PA 1
Oct. 6, 1905 F 1905 Philadelphia XI 1 - 4 Pilgrims Germantown, PA 1
Oct. 5, 1905 F 1905 Philadelphia Thistles 0 - 5 Pilgrims Philadelphia, PA 1
Oct. 1, 1905 F 1905 Chicago XI 2 - 1 Pilgrims Chicago, IL 1
Sept. 30, 1905 F 1905 Chicago XI 0 - 6 Pilgrims Chicago, IL 1
Sept. 24, 1905 F 1905 Pilgrims 6 - 0 St. Louis XI St. Louis, MO 2
Sept. 23, 1905 F 1905 Pilgrims 10 - 0 St. Louis XI St. Louis, MO 2
Sept. 18, 1905 F 1905 Detroit Peninsulars 2 - 10 Pilgrims Detroit, MI 1
Sept. 16, 1905 F 1905 Galt F.C. 3 - 3 Pilgrims Dickson Park, Galt, ON James Bennett 3500 2
Sept. 13, 1905 F 1905 Berlin Rangers 2 - 1 Pilgrims Berlin, ON Harry Brown 3000 1
Sept. 12, 1905 F 1905 Niagara Falls XI 0 - 5 Pilgrims Niagara Falls, ON W.H. Nuttall 1
Sept. 11, 1905 F 1905 Hamilton XI 2 - 8 Pilgrims Hamilton, ON J.D. Bryning 700 1
Sept. 9, 1905 F 1905 Montreal XI 0 - 5 Pilgrims MAAA Grounds Radforth 2500 1