| Nov. 16, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Crescent A.C. |
1 - 6 |
Pilgrims |
Brooklyn, NY |
Harlan |
450 |
2 |
| Nov. 14, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
New York Amateur League |
2 - 2 |
Pilgrims |
Meyerrose Park |
J. Evans |
1200 |
2 |
| Nov. 13, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Fall River Rovers |
2 - 1 |
Pilgrims |
Fall River, MA |
|
3965 |
2 |
| Nov. 10, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Fall River Rovers |
1 - 1 |
Pilgrims |
Fall River, MA |
|
2821 |
2 |
| Nov. 6, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Pennsylvania League Stars |
0 - 9 |
Pilgrims |
Philadelphia, PA |
|
4586 |
1 |
| Nov. 4, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Haverford College |
1 - 0 |
Pilgrims |
Philadelphia, PA |
|
1077 |
2 |
| Nov. 2, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Philadelphia Cricket Clubs Stars |
0 - 3 |
Pilgrims |
Philadelphia, PA |
|
800 |
1 |
| Oct. 31, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Pilgrims |
12 - 0 |
St. Leo's |
St. Louis, MO |
|
4300 |
2 |
| Oct. 30, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Pilgrims |
4 - 0 |
Western All-Stars |
St. Louis, MO |
|
1200 |
2 |
| Oct. 26, 1909 |
F |
1909 |
Coal City Maroons |
0 - 0 |
Pilgrims |
Coal City, IL |
|
450 |
1 |