Dec. 25, 1888 F 1888-1889 Newark Tiffany Rovers W - L Paterson True Blues Newark, NJ 1
Nov. 24, 1888 AFAC 1888-1889 1 Newark Caledonians 4 - 1 Newark Tiffany Rovers Clark ONT Field A. Craig 2
Nov. 10, 1888 F 1888-1889 Newark Caledonians 1 - 0 Newark Tiffany Rovers Newark, NJ 2
Nov. 10, 1888 AFAC 1888-1889 1 Newark Caledonians 1 - 0 Newark Tiffany Rovers Newark, NJ 0
Oct. 27, 1888 AFAC 1888-1889 Newark Caledonians 4 - 4 Newark Tiffany Rovers Clark ONT Field 2
Dec. 25, 1887 F 1887-1888 Newark Caledonians 1 - 5 Newark Tiffany Rovers Newark, NJ 1
Dec. 17, 1887 F 1887-1888 Newark Caledonians 6 - 1 Newark Tiffany Rovers Newark, NJ 1
Nov. 24, 1887 F 1887-1888 Newark Tiffany Rovers 2 - 1 Trenton Young Americans Chambersburg, NJ 1
Nov. 21, 1887 F 1887-1888 Newark Tiffany Rovers 2 - 1 Trenton Young Americans Chambersburg, NJ 1
Oct. 22, 1887 F 1887-1888 Newark Tiffany Rovers 0 - 4 Patersons Association Newark, NJ 2
Oct. 22, 1887 AFAC 1887-1888 Newark Tiffany Rovers 0 - 4 Paterson Wright Street Grounds J. Howarth 0
Oct. 17, 1887 F 1887-1888 Newark Caledonians 4 - 7 Newark Tiffany Rovers Newark, NJ 1
Oct. 15, 1887 F 1887-1888 Newark Caledonians 4 - 7 Newark Tiffany Rovers Newark, NJ 1
Feb. 22, 1887 F 1886-1887 Newark Caledonians 0 - 0 Newark Tiffany Rovers Newark, NJ 1
Feb. 19, 1887 F 1886-1887 Newark Almas 9 - 0 Newark Tiffany Rovers neutral 1
Jan. 1, 1887 F 1886-1887 Newark Tiffany Rovers ? Trentons Association East State Street Grounds 1
Nov. 27, 1886 F 1886-1887 New York Pilgrims L - W Newark Tiffany Rovers New York, NY 1
Nov. 25, 1886 F 1886-1887 New York Pilgrims 2 - 1 Newark Tiffany Rovers New York, NY 2
Oct. 23, 1886 AFAC 1886-1887 Kearney Rangers 4 - 0 Newark Tiffany Rovers Clark ONT Field J. Joules 1
Feb. 19, 1886 F 1886-1887 Newark Almas 9 - 0 Newark Tiffany Rovers neutral 1
April 25, 1885 F 1884-1885 Newark Almas 0 - 0 Newark Tiffany Rovers neutral 1
April 4, 1885 F 1884-1885 Newark Almas 1 - 1 Newark Tiffany Rovers Newark, NJ 1