- 11/27/1886 +
Nov. 27, 1886 F 1886-1887 Ashton Association 0 - 3 Providence Association Providence Association 700 1
Nov. 27, 1886 F 1886-1887 Berkeley Association 0 - 2 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Dexter Street Grounds 1
Nov. 27, 1886 F 1886-1887 New York Pilgrims L - W Newark Tiffany Rovers New York, NY 1