Dec. 29, 1895 NAFBL 1895-1896 International AC 7 - 1 New York Thistles Communipaw, NJ H. Fitzpatrick 0
Dec. 23, 1895 NAFBL 1895-1896 Kearny Scots 7 - 1 New York Thistles Newark, NJ R. Stockton 0
Dec. 15, 1895 NAFBL 1895-1896 Centreville AC 4 - 2 New York Thistles Bayonne, NJ Archie Gray 600 0
April 5, 1891 F 1890-1891 New York Thistles ? Williamsburg Shamrocks New York, NY 1
March 29, 1891 F 1890-1891 New York Thistles ? Williamsburg Shamrocks New York, NY 1
March 22, 1891 F 1890-1891 Brooklyn Longfellows ? New York Thistles New York, NY 1
March 15, 1891 F 1890-1891 Brooklyn Longfellows 5 - 5 New York Thistles New York, NY 1
Nov. 2, 1890 F 1890-1891 Brooklyn Longfellows 2 - 1 New York Thistles Brooklyn, NY 1
Oct. 18, 1890 AFAC 1890-1891 1 Kearney Rovers 1 - 0 New York Thistles 1
Oct. 11, 1890 NYSS 1890-1891 1 Brooklyn Longfellows 9 - 1 New York Thistles Brooklyn, NY 1
Sept. 14, 1890 F 1890-1891 Brooklyn Longfellows 5 - 0 New York Thistles Brooklyn, NY 1
Aug. 16, 1890 F 1890-1891 Brooklyn Longfellows 3 - 1 New York Thistles Ridgewood Baseball Grounds 1
May 18, 1890 F 1889-1890 New York Nonpareils W - L New York Thistles New York Nonpareils 1
Feb. 22, 1890 F 1889-1890 New York Thistles 7 - 0 Williamsburg Brooklyns Ridgewood Baseball Grounds 1
Feb. 16, 1890 F 1889-1890 New York Nonpareils 2 - 4 New York Thistles New York Nonpareils 400 1
Jan. 26, 1890 F 1889-1890 Brooklyn Longfellows 2 - 4 New York Thistles Brooklyn, NY 300 1
Jan. 19, 1890 F 1889-1890 New York Nonpareils 1 - 2 New York Thistles New York Nonpareils 1
Dec. 25, 1889 F 1889-1890 New York Nonpareils 0 - 0 New York Thistles Ridgewood Baseball Grounds 1
Nov. 23, 1889 AFAC 1889-1890 New York Thistles 2 - 2 Trenton Potters New York, NY 2
Oct. 19, 1889 AFAC 1889-1890 1 New York Thistles 15 - 1 Newark Caledonians 1
Oct. 12, 1889 AFAC 1889-1890 New York Thistles 15 - 1 Newark Caledonians Clark ONT Field 1
Sept. 7, 1889 F 1889-1890 New York Thistles 4 - 6 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Dexter Street Grounds 1500 1
April 6, 1889 F 1888-1889 Brooklyn Longfellows 1 - 4 New York Thistles Brooklyn, NY 1
Feb. 9, 1889 F 1888-1889 Brooklyn Longfellows 0 - 6 New York Thistles Brooklyn, NY 1
Feb. 2, 1889 AFAC 1888-1889 sf Brooklyn Longfellows 0 - 6 New York Thistles 2
Jan. 1, 1889 AFAC 1888-1889 2 Kearney Clarks ONT 0 - 4 New York Thistles Clark Field 1
Dec. 25, 1888 AFAC 1888-1889 sf New York Thistles 4 - 5 Newark Caledonians Clark ONT Field W. Turner 2
Nov. 29, 1888 F 1888-1889 New York Thistles 0 - 1 Newark Almas Newark, NJ 1
Nov. 10, 1888 F 1888-1889 New York Thistles 7 - 1 Paterson Rangers 0
Nov. 10, 1888 AFAC 1888-1889 2 New York Thistles 7 - 1 Paterson Rangers 3
Oct. 20, 1888 AFAC 1888-1889 1 New York Thistles 3 - 1 Trentons Association Trenton, NJ 2
Sept. 3, 1888 F 1888-1889 New York Thistles W - L Trenton Rovers New York, NY 0
Sept. 3, 1888 AFAC 1888-1889 1 New York Thistles W - L Trenton Rovers Trenton, NJ 2
Feb. 10, 1888 F 1887-1888 Brooklyn Longfellows 0 - 6 New York Thistles Ridgewood Baseball Grounds 1
Dec. 25, 1887 F 1887-1888 Kearney Clarks ONT 3 - 4 New York Thistles Clark Field 1
Dec. 15, 1887 F 1887-1888 Kearney Clarks ONT 3 - 4 New York Thistles Clark Field 1
Nov. 12, 1887 AFAC 1887-1888 Ansonia Association 1 - 0 New York Thistles Metropolitan Park 2
Nov. 8, 1887 F 1887-1888 Brooklyn Longfellows 0 - 3 New York Thistles Prospect Park 1
Oct. 22, 1887 AFAC 1887-1888 Ansonia Association ? New York Thistles Metropolitan Park 1
Oct. 1, 1887 F 1887-1888 New York Riversides L - W New York Thistles Central Park 1