March 9, 1958 Brookhattan 3 - 4 Hakoah (ASL2)

ASL2	1957-1958	Baltimore Pompei	3 - 1	Polish Falcons	Kahler Park, Baltimore, MD	1
ASL2	1957-1958	Newark Portuguese	2 - 2	Philadelphia German Americans	Edison Field	1
ASL2	1957-1958	Brooklyn Italians	2 - 3	Fall River SC	Lafayette High School, Brooklyn, NY	1

March 9, 1958	ASL2	1957-1958	Brookhattan	3 - 4	Hakoah (ASL2)	Zerega Oval	1
Oct. 20, 1957	ASL2	1957-1958	Brookhattan	4 - 2	Hakoah (ASL2)	Zerega Oval	1