- 3/9/1958 +
March 9, 1958 ASL2 1957-1958 Brookhattan 3 - 4 Hakoah (ASL2) Zerega Oval 1
March 9, 1958 ASL2 1957-1958 Baltimore Pompei 3 - 1 Polish Falcons Kahler Park, Baltimore, MD 1
March 9, 1958 ASL2 1957-1958 Newark Portuguese 2 - 2 Philadelphia German Americans Edison Field 1
March 9, 1958 ASL2 1957-1958 Brooklyn Italians 2 - 3 Fall River SC Lafayette High School, Brooklyn, NY 1