- 2/1/1891 +
Feb. 1, 1891 F 1890-1891 Chicago Swifts 1 - 4 Chicago Thistles Wanderers Grounds 1
Feb. 1, 1891 F 1890-1891 East St. Louis Blue Bells 2 - 0 Missouri Amateur AA 1
Feb. 1, 1891 F 1890-1891 St. Louis Hibernians 0 - 1 St. Louis Kensingtons 1
Feb. 1, 1891 F 1890-1891 St. Louis Olympics 0 - 1 St. Louis Shamrocks 1