| cmp | date | team | score | vs | g | a | minutes | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F | Oct. 24, 1905 | Pilgrims | 10 - 0 | University of Pennsylvania | 0 | 90 | Franklin Field | ||
| F | Oct. 21, 1905 | Pilgrims | 1 - 7 | New York XI | 0 | 90 | Polo Grounds | ||
| F | Oct. 16, 1905 | Pilgrims | 0 - 5 | Boston XI | 0 | 90 | South Ends Grounds, Boston, MA | ||
| F | Oct. 14, 1905 | Pilgrims | 3 - 4 | Fall River XI | 0 | 90 | Bedford Street Athletic Grounds | ||
| F | Sept. 16, 1905 | Pilgrims | 3 - 3 | Galt F.C. | 0 | 90 | Dickson Park, Galt, ON | ||
| F | Sept. 13, 1905 | Pilgrims | 2 - 1 | Berlin Rangers | 0 | 90 | Berlin, ON | ||
| F | Sept. 9, 1905 | Pilgrims | 0 - 5 | Montreal XI | 0 | 90 | MAAA Grounds |