| cmp | date | team | score | vs | g | a | minutes | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F | Nov. 14, 1909 | Pilgrims | 2 - 2 | New York Amateur League | 0 | 90 | Meyerrose Park | ||
| F | Oct. 12, 1909 | Pilgrims | 2 - 1 | Trenton XI | 2 | 90 | Wilbur Baseball Grounds, Trenton, NJ | ||
| F | Oct. 10, 1909 | Pilgrims | 0 - 5 | Kearny Scots | 0 | 90 | Newark Baseball Grounds, Newark, NJ |