Feb. 23, 1890 F 1889-1890 St. Louis Hibernians T - T St. Louis Hibernians 2nds neutral 2
Nov. 14, 1886 F 1886-1887 St. Louis Hibernians W - L St. Louis Hibernians 2nds Union Park 1
Nov. 23, 1884 F 1884-1885 St. Louis Hibernians W - L St. Louis Hibernians 2nds 1
March 16, 1884 F 1883-1884 St. Louis Hibernians 2 - 0 St. Louis Hibernians 2nds neutral 1