April 11, 1891 F 1890-1891 Lonsdale Association 2 - 2 Pawtucket Thistles Dexter Street Grounds 1
April 4, 1891 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Thistles 2 - 3 Providence Conant Thread Company Prospect Hill Park 1
March 28, 1891 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Thistles 1 - 0 Saylesville Athletics Pawtucket Thistles 1
Feb. 21, 1891 F 1890-1891 Lonsdale Athletes L - W Pawtucket Thistles Pawtucket Thistles 1
Feb. 7, 1891 F 1890-1891 Lonsdale Association 1 - 4 Pawtucket Thistles Pawtucket Thistles 1
Jan. 31, 1891 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Free Wanderers 8 - 1 Pawtucket Thistles Pawtucket Thistles 1
Jan. 24, 1891 F 1890-1891 Lonsdale Athletes 1 - 3 Pawtucket Thistles Lonsdale Athletes 1
Jan. 3, 1891 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Free Wanderers np Pawtucket Thistles Dexter Street Grounds 1
Dec. 6, 1890 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Thistles 1 - 0 Thornton Rovers Pawtucket Thistles 1
Nov. 27, 1890 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Thistles 6 - 2 River Point Clydes River Point, RI 1
Nov. 22, 1890 F 1890-1891 Cumberland Rangers 2 - 2 Pawtucket Thistles Cumberland, RI 1
Nov. 15, 1890 F 1890-1891 Lonsdale Association 1 - 3 Pawtucket Thistles Pawtucket Thistles 1
Nov. 8, 1890 F 1890-1891 Oak Grove Ramblers 1 - 0 Pawtucket Thistles Pawtucket Thistles 1
Nov. 1, 1890 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Thistles 2 - 5 River Point Clydes Pawtucket Thistles 1000 1
Oct. 25, 1890 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Thistles 7 - 2 Providence Conant Thread Company Providence, RI 1000 1
Oct. 18, 1890 F 1890-1891 Lonsdale Association 1 - 5 Pawtucket Thistles 1
Sept. 27, 1890 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Thistles 0 - 2 Providence Athletics 1
Sept. 20, 1890 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Thistles 5 - 1 Providence Conant Thread Company Pawtucket Thistles 1
April 12, 1890 F 1889-1890 Manville Athletics 2 - 5 Pawtucket Thistles 1
March 8, 1890 F 1889-1890 Cumberland Rangers L - W Pawtucket Thistles 1
March 1, 1890 F 1889-1890 Manville Athletics 0 - 4 Pawtucket Thistles Pawtucket Thistles 1