May 21, 1887 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 2 - 2 Providence Association Providence Association 400 1
April 30, 1887 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 1 - 2 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Cottage Street Grounds 1
March 26, 1887 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 1 - 9 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Cottage Street Grounds 1
March 19, 1887 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 3 - 1 Providence Association Dexter Street Grounds 1
March 12, 1887 F 1886-1887 Fall River East Ends 5 - 3 Olneyville Thorntons Fall River, MA 2
Feb. 26, 1887 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 1 - 0 Providence Association Cottage Street Grounds 1
Feb. 12, 1887 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 2 - 0 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Dexter Street Grounds 350 1
Jan. 30, 1887 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 0 - 4 Thornton Rovers Thornton, RI 1
Dec. 25, 1886 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons W - L Providence Association Providence, RI 1
Dec. 11, 1886 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons W - L River Point Clydes 1
Nov. 25, 1886 F 1886-1887 Fall River Rovers 7 - 1 Olneyville Thorntons North Ends Grounds 1
Nov. 20, 1886 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 2 - 0 Pawtucket Lorraines Saylesville, RI 1
Nov. 13, 1886 F 1886-1887 Berkeley Association 0 - 3 Olneyville Thorntons Ashton Park 1
Nov. 6, 1886 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 1 - 1 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Messer Street Park 1
Oct. 23, 1886 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 2 - 0 Providence Association Messer Street Park 200 1
Oct. 16, 1886 F 1886-1887 Fall River Rovers 3 - 2 Olneyville Thorntons Fall River, MA 1
Oct. 9, 1886 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons ? River Point Clydes River Point, RI 1
Sept. 25, 1886 F 1886-1887 Olneyville Thorntons 4 - 2 Olneyville Thorntons 2nds neutral 1
Sept. 18, 1886 F 1886-1887 Lincoln Rovers 0 - 2 Olneyville Thorntons Providence, RI 1
April 17, 1886 F 1885-1886 Olneyville Thorntons 0 - 1 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Dexter Street Grounds 1750 1
April 3, 1886 F 1885-1886 Olneyville Thorntons W - 0 Providence Association Providence Association 1
March 27, 1886 F 1885-1886 Olneyville Thorntons 2 - 0 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Providence, RI 1
March 20, 1886 F 1885-1886 Berkeley Association 1 - 2 Olneyville Thorntons Cumberland, RI 1
Feb. 20, 1886 F 1885-1886 Berkeley Association 0 - 3 Olneyville Thorntons Providence, RI 1
Jan. 30, 1886 F 1885-1886 Olneyville Thorntons 4 - 0 Providence Association Providence Association 1
Dec. 26, 1885 F 1885-1886 Ashton Association 0 - 1 Olneyville Thorntons Cumberland, RI 1