Jan. 20, 1924 AFAC 1923-1924 Brooklyn Wanderers 4 - 2 Newark F.C. Wanderers Stadium T. Cunningham 2
Nov. 22, 1914 USOC 1915 1 Bronx United 3 - 0 Newark F.C. 1
May 11, 1912 AAFAC 1911-1912 Brooklyn Celtic 3 - 0 Newark F.C. 3500 0
April 14, 1912 AAFAC 1911-1912 Newark F.C. 5 - 2 Yonkers Hollywood Inn 0
Dec. 27, 1908 AFAC 1908-1909 qf Fall River Rovers 6 - 1 Newark F.C. 0
Nov. 18, 1906 NAFBL 1906-1907 Kearny AC 1 - 3 Newark F.C. Morris Park A. Andrews 1
Nov. 17, 1906 NAFBL 1906-1907 Gordon Rangers 0 - 8 Newark F.C. W. Ritchie 1
Oct. 28, 1906 NAFBL 1906-1907 Newark F.C. 4 - 0 St. George Club 1