April 21, 1886 F 1885-1886 New York Continentals 0 - 2 New York Riversides neutral 1
April 3, 1886 F 1885-1886 New York Continentals 0 - 3 New York Riversides Prospect Park 1
Dec. 28, 1885 F 1885-1886 New York Continentals 0 - 1 New York Riversides Olympic Rink 1
Dec. 22, 1885 F 1885-1886 New York Continentals T - T New York Riversides Olympic Rink 1