Oct. 19, 1919 AFAC 1919-1920 Longfellow Club 1 - 1 Newburgh Shipyards Ridgewood Baseball Grounds 1
Sept. 22, 1894 F 1894-1895 Longfellow Club ? New York Giants Polo Grounds Thomas Bright 1
Dec. 19, 1891 AFAC 1891-1892 Longfellow Club 4 - 2 Thistle 1