Oct. 6, 1917 NAFBL 1917-1918 Bethlehem Steel 10 - 0 Jersey City FC Steel Field James Walders 1
April 30, 1916 AFAC 1915-1916 Bethlehem Steel 5 - 0 Jersey City FC Jersey City, NJ Creighton 1
April 4, 1914 AFAC 1913-1914 Bethlehem Steel 2 - 1 Jersey City FC East End Field 1
March 29, 1914 AFAC 1913-1914 Bethlehem Steel 2 - 2 Jersey City FC Jersey City, NJ 1