Jan. 5, 1913 AAFAC 1912-1913 Clan MacDonald FC 2 - 0 Critchley FC Brooklyn, NY 0
April 14, 1912 AAFAC 1911-1912 Brooklyn Celtic 5 - 0 Critchley FC Brooklyn, NY 0
March 17, 1912 AAFAC 1911-1912 Critchley FC 2 - 0 Sheffield AFC 0