April 1, 1962 ASL2 1961-1962 Brooklyn 3 - 0 Brooklyn Italians 1
Jan. 9, 1916 AFAC 1915-1916 Brooklyn 1 - 0 I.R.T. Strollers Harlem Oval 1
Nov. 29, 1908 AFAC 1908-1909 Brooklyn 1 - 2 Howard & Bullough Marquette Oval Stewart Rahway 0