Nov. 12, 1922 USOC 1923 2 Bay Ridge FC 1 - 2 Hartford Rovers 1
Oct. 15, 1922 USOC 1923 1 Bay Ridge FC 3 - 0 British Great War Veterans 1
Feb. 18, 1917 USOC 1917 2 Bay Ridge FC 1 - 2 Kearny Scots East Newark, NJ Thomas Cunningham 2
Nov. 19, 1916 USOC 1917 1 Bay Ridge FC 1 - 0 Clan MacDuff FC Brooklyn, NY Charles Creighton 2
Nov. 12, 1916 AFAC 1916-1917 Bay Ridge FC 2 - 1 Kearny Celtic Hawthorne Field 2