Wessington Stadium, Clifton, NJ, United States

1939-1940 Brooklyn Hispano 3 - 2 Paterson FC (ASL2) 2
1939-1940 Kearny Scots 3 - 1 Paterson FC (ASL2) 2
1939-1940 Paterson FC (ASL2) 1 - 1 Philadelphia Passon 2
1937-1938 Baltimore S.C. 2 - 3 Paterson Caledonian 2
1937-1938 Kearny Celtic 1 - 1 Paterson Caledonian 2
1936-1937 Kearny Celtic 1 - 2 Paterson Caledonian 2
1936-1937 New York Americans 2 - 1 Paterson Caledonian 2