Dec. 25, 1888 New York Thistles 4 - 5 Newark Caledonians

AFAC	1888-1889	2	Kearney Clarks ONT	5 - 3	Newark Almas	Clark Field	2
F	1888-1889		Lowell Rovers	1 - 9	Pawtucket Free Wanderers	Dexter Street Grounds	1
F	1888-1889		Fall River Olympics	1 - 1	Pawtucket Free Wanderers	Dexter Street Grounds	1
F	1888-1889		Newark Tiffany Rovers	W - L	Paterson True Blues	Newark, NJ	1
F	1888-1889		Palo Alto Mayfields	5 - 4	San Francisco California Rangers	San Francisco, CA	1
F	1888-1889		Providence Association	3 - 2	River Point Clydes	Providence Association	1
F	1888-1889		Kearney Clarks ONT	5 - 3	Newark Almas	Clark Field	0