- 1/3/1891 +
Jan. 3, 1891 F 1890-1891 Fall River East Ends 1 - 1 Fall River Olympics neutral 1
Jan. 3, 1891 F 1890-1891 Pawtucket Free Wanderers np Pawtucket Thistles Dexter Street Grounds 1
Jan. 3, 1891 F 1890-1891 Philadelphia Frankfords np Philadelphia Taconeys Philadelphia Taconeys 1
Jan. 3, 1891 F 1890-1891 Philadelphia Manayunks 0 - 1 Philadelphia Oxfords neutral 1
Jan. 3, 1891 F 1890-1891 Philadelphia Nicetowns 1 - 2 Philadelphia North Ends 1