- 9/7/1889 +
Sept. 7, 1889 F 1889-1890 Lonsdale Association 4 - 1 Lonsdale Rovers neutral 1
Sept. 7, 1889 F 1889-1890 Cumberland Rangers 1 - 0 Manville Athletics Manville Athletics 1
Sept. 7, 1889 F 1889-1890 New York Thistles 4 - 6 Pawtucket Free Wanderers Dexter Street Grounds 1500 1