- 3/9/1889 +
March 9, 1889 F 1888-1889 Cumberland Rangers 0 - 1 Rumsford Olympics Berkeley, RI 1
March 9, 1889 F 1888-1889 Lonsdale Association 0 - 0 Thornton Rovers Thornton, RI 1
March 9, 1889 F 1888-1889 Brooklyn Longfellows 2 - 5 Newark Caledonians Brooklyn, NY 1
March 9, 1889 F 1888-1889 Pawtucket Free Wanderers 7 - 0 Providence Association Dexter Street Grounds 1