- 12/8/1889 +
Dec. 8, 1889 AFAC 1889-1890 3 Brooklyn Longfellows 4 - 2 New York Nonpareils neutral 0
Dec. 8, 1889 F 1889-1890 Christian Brothers College 0 - 0 St. Louis Olympics 1
Dec. 8, 1889 F 1889-1890 Brooklyn Longfellows 4 - 2 New York Nonpareils neutral 2
Dec. 8, 1889 F 1889-1890 St. Louis Hibernians 0 - 0 St. Louis Shamrocks 1
Dec. 8, 1889 F 1889-1890 St. Louis Kensingtons 0 - 0 St. Louis Pastimes 1