- 12/14/1889 +
Dec. 14, 1889 AFAC 1889-1890 2 Pawtucket Free Wanderers 4 - 2 Providence Athletics Dexter Street Grounds 600 1
Dec. 14, 1889 F 1889-1890 Quincy High School 1 - 0 Quincy University 1
Dec. 14, 1889 F 1889-1890 Cumberland Rangers 2 - 0 Lonsdale Association Cumberland, RI 2
Dec. 14, 1889 F 1889-1890 Fall River Athletes 0 - 1 Fall River Olympics North Ends Grounds 1
Dec. 14, 1889 F 1889-1890 Lonsdale Association 1 - 1 River Point Clydes Lonsdale, RI 0