- 11/7/1874 +
Nov. 7, 1874 F 1874-1875 Columbia University 4 - 1 Rutgers University St. George's Cricket Grounds 2
Nov. 7, 1874 F 1874-1875 Dartmouth 1875/1877 3 - 0 Dartmouth 1876/1878 1
Nov. 7, 1874 F 1874-1875 New Brunswick Public High School 0 - 6 Rutgers Grammar School Rats 1