1916-1917 AFA Cup

Oct. 15, 1916 1916-1917 Alley Boys 3 - 1 Splitdorf F.C. Clark ONT Field 1
Oct. 28, 1916 1916-1917 Bethlehem Steel 6 - 1 Philadelphia Hibernian Steel Field George Allen 2
Oct. 29, 1916 1916-1917 Clan MacDuff FC 0 - 1 New York Field Club Harlem Oval 1
Oct. 29, 1916 1916-1917 Babcock & Wilcox 4 - 1 Greenpoint FC Bayonne, NJ 1
Nov. 12, 1916 1916-1917 Bay Ridge FC 2 - 1 Kearny Celtic Hawthorne Field 2
Nov. 26, 1916 1916-1917 Bridgeport City 1 - 3 New York Field Club Harlem Oval 2000 1
Dec. 3, 1916 1916-1917 Brooklyn Celtic 6 - 0 Falls Cricket and Football Club Harlem Oval 2
Dec. 3, 1916 1916-1917 Continentals 2 - 1 Schenectady General Electric Lenox Oval 2
Dec. 3, 1916 1916-1917 Clan MacDonald FC 0 - 1 Paterson Dublins Hawthorne Field 2
Dec. 9, 1916 1916-1917 Bethlehem Steel 2 - 0 Disston Steel Field Andrew Laurie 1
Jan. 21, 1917 1916-1917 3 Clan MacDonald FC 4 - 1 Continentals Lenox Oval 1
Jan. 28, 1917 1916-1917 3 Bethlehem Steel 2 - 1 New York Field Club Harlem Oval T. Cunningham 5000 2
March 10, 1917 1916-1917 sf Brooklyn Celtic v West Hudson AA 1
March 11, 1917 1916-1917 sf Bethlehem Steel 5 - 0 Clan MacDonald FC East Newark, NJ Andrew Lawrie 2
May 13, 1917 1916-1917 f Bethlehem Steel 7 - 0 West Hudson AA Weidenmayer's Park Charles Creighton 5000 1