← 1909-1910 AFA Cup →

Nov. 28, 1909 1909-1910 2 Brooklyn FC 1 - 1 Paterson True Blues Marquette Oval 1
Nov. 28, 1909 1909-1910 2 Paterson Rangers 3 - 1 Philadelphia Corinthians 1
Dec. 5, 1909 1909-1910 2 Brooklyn FC 1 - 3 Paterson True Blues 1
Dec. 11, 1909 1909-1910 2 Celtic FC (USA) 1 - 3 Disston 1
Feb. 7, 1910 1909-1910 qf Kearny Scots 1 - 0 West Hudson AA 1
March 6, 1910 1909-1910 qf Disston 4 - 1 Paterson Rangers 1
March 12, 1910 1909-1910 qf Fall River Rovers 2 - 2 Jersey A.C. 1
March 26, 1910 1909-1910 sf Disston 2 - 1 Fall River Rovers 1
March 27, 1910 1909-1910 sf Kearny Scots 1 - 1 Paterson True Blues 1
April 24, 1910 1909-1910 f Disston 2 - 1 Kearny Scots West Hudson Athletic Field 7000 1