← 1908-1909 AFA Cup →

Oct. 25, 1908 1908-1909 Brooklyn Camerons 4 - 3 Trenton Caledonians Trenton, NJ 0
Nov. 7, 1908 1908-1909 Manhattan Caledonian 0 - 2 Yonkers Hollywood Inn Westchester, NY T. Kearns 1
Nov. 29, 1908 1908-1909 Brooklyn 1 - 2 Howard & Bullough Marquette Oval Stewart Rahway 0
Dec. 27, 1908 1908-1909 qf Clan MacDonald FC 0 - 1 Kearney Clarks ONT 0
Dec. 27, 1908 1908-1909 qf Howard & Bullough 1 - 0 Paterson True Blues Ryle Park 0
Dec. 27, 1908 1908-1909 qf Fall River Rovers 6 - 1 Newark F.C. 0
Jan. 1, 1909 1908-1909 qf Brooklyn Camerons 1 - 1 Jersey A.C. Williamsbridge 0
Jan. 10, 1909 1908-1909 qf Brooklyn Camerons 1 - 1 Jersey A.C. Jersey City, NJ 0
Feb. 28, 1909 1908-1909 qf Brooklyn Camerons 0 - 2 Jersey A.C. Paterson, NJ 0
March 28, 1909 1908-1909 sf Jersey City AC 3 - 4 Paterson True Blues Paterson, NJ J. Kearns 1
April 18, 1909 1908-1909 f Kearney Clarks ONT 1 - 1 Paterson True Blues Harrison, NJ 0
May 2, 1909 1908-1909 f Kearney Clarks ONT 1 - 2 Paterson True Blues Harrison Oval James Nesbitt 10000 0