USL Second Division | Champion

1995 Long Island Rough Riders
1996 Charleston Battery
1997 Sacramento Geckos
1998 Chicago Sockers
1999 Western Mass Pioneers
2000 Charlotte Eagles
2001 Utah Blitzz
2002 Long Island Rough Riders
2003 Wilmington Hammerheads
2004 Utah Blitzz
2005 Charlotte Eagles
2006 Richmond Kickers
2007 Harrisburg City Islanders
2008 Cleveland City Stars
2009 Richmond Kickers
2010 Charleston Battery
2011 Orlando City SC
2012 Charleston Battery
2013 Orlando City SC