USL First Division | Defender of the Year

1998 Scott Schweitzer
1999 Scott Schweitzer
2000 Scott Cannon
2001 Rick Titus
2002 Mark Watson
2003 Gabriel Gervais
2004 Gabriel Gervais
2005 Taylor Graham
2006 Gabriel Gervais
2007 David Hayes
2008 Cristian Arrieta
2009 Cristian Arrieta