National Association Foot Ball League | Champion

1895 Centreville AC
1896-1897 Kearny Scots
1897-1898 Paterson True Blues
1898-1899 Paterson True Blues
1906-1907 West Hudson AA
1907-1908 Newark F.C.
1908-1909 Kearney Clarks ONT
1908-1909 West Hudson AA
1909-1910 West Hudson AA
1910-1911 Newark F.C.
1911-1912 West Hudson AA
1912-1913 West Hudson AA
1913-1914 Brooklyn FC
1914-1915 West Hudson AA
1915-1916 Harrison Alley Boys
1916-1917 Jersey A.C.
1917-1918 Paterson FC
1918-1919 Bethlehem Steel
1919-1920 Bethlehem Steel
1920-1921 Bethlehem Steel