NCAA Division I | Horizon League Tournament Champion

1987 University of Evansville
1988 University of Notre Dame
1989 University of Evansville
1990 University of Evansville
1991 University of Evansville
1992 University of Evansville
1993 University of Notre Dame
1994 University of Notre Dame
1995 Butler University
1996 University of Detroit Mercy
1997 Butler University
1998 Butler University
1999 University of Illinois at Chicago
2000 University of Illinois at Chicago
2001 Butler University
2002 University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
2003 University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
2004 University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
2005 University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
2006 Loyola University Chicago
2007 University of Illinois at Chicago
2008 Loyola University Chicago
2009 University of Wisconsin-Green Bay
2010 Butler University