| 1959 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1960 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1961 |
West Chester University of Pennsylvania |
| 1962 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1963 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1964 |
United States Naval Academy |
| 1965 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1966 |
University of San Francisco |
| 1967 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1967 |
Michigan State University |
| 1968 |
University of Maryland |
| 1968 |
Michigan State University |
| 1969 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1970 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1971 |
Howard University |
| 1972 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1973 |
Saint Louis University |
| 1974 |
Howard University |
| 1975 |
University of San Francisco |
| 1976 |
University of San Francisco |
| 1977 |
Hartwick College |
| 1978 |
University of San Francisco |
| 1979 |
SIU Edwardsville |
| 1980 |
University of San Francisco |
| 1981 |
University of Connecticut |
| 1982 |
Indiana University |
| 1983 |
Indiana University |
| 1984 |
Clemson University |
| 1985 |
UCLA |
| 1986 |
Duke University |
| 1987 |
Clemson University |
| 1988 |
Indiana University |
| 1989 |
University of Virginia |
| 1989 |
Santa Clara University |
| 1990 |
UCLA |
| 1991 |
University of Virginia |
| 1992 |
University of Virginia |
| 1993 |
University of Virginia |
| 1994 |
University of Virginia |
| 1995 |
University of Wisconsin |
| 1996 |
St. John's University |
| 1997 |
UCLA |
| 1998 |
Indiana University |
| 1999 |
Indiana University |
| 2000 |
University of Connecticut |
| 2001 |
University of North Carolina |
| 2002 |
UCLA |
| 2003 |
Indiana University |
| 2004 |
Indiana University |
| 2005 |
University of Maryland |
| 2006 |
University of California, Santa Barbara |
| 2007 |
Wake Forest University |
| 2008 |
University of Maryland |
| 2009 |
University of Virginia |
| 2010 |
University of Akron |
| 2011 |
University of North Carolina |
| 2012 |
Indiana University |
| 2013 |
University of Notre Dame |