Major League Soccer | Supporters' Shield

1996 Tampa Bay Mutiny
1997 D.C. United
1998 LA Galaxy
1999 D.C. United
2000 Sporting Kansas City
2001 Miami Fusion
2002 LA Galaxy
2003 Chicago Fire
2004 Columbus Crew
2005 San Jose Earthquakes
2006 D.C. United
2007 D.C. United
2008 Columbus Crew
2009 Columbus Crew
2010 LA Galaxy
2011 LA Galaxy
2012 San Jose Earthquakes
2013 New York Red Bulls