National Professional Soccer League (indoor) | Defender of the Year

1984-1985 Oscar Pisano
1985-1986 Oscar Pisano
1986-1987 Tim Tyma
1987-1988 Tim Tyma
1988-1989 Tim Tyma
1989-1990 Bret Hall
1990-1991 Denzil Antonio
1991-1992 Matt Knowles
1992-1993 Kim Røntved
1993-1994 Sean Bowers
1994-1995 Sean Bowers
1995-1996 Matt Knowles
1996-1997 Daryl Doran
1997-1998 Matt Knowles
1998-1999 Kevin Hundelt
1999-2000 James Dunn