USL Second Division | Defender of the Year

1996 Guy Norcott
1997 Omid Namazi
1998 Lovelace Ackah
1999 Adetoye Oshoniyi
2000 Adolfo Ovalle
2001 Luciano Faccilongo
2002 Steve Danbusky
2003 David Palmer
2004 Tim Karalexis
2005 Josh Rife
2006 Gary Sullivan
2007 Mark Schulte
2008 Mark Schulte
2009 Yomby William
2010 Shintaro Harada
2011 Rob Valentino
2012 Troy Roberts
2013 Colin Falvey