NCAA Division I | Big East Defensive Player of the Year

1991 Jon Urbom
1992 Kieran Walsh
1993 Paul Eduards
1994 Phil Wellington
1995 Doug Nevins
1996 Brandon Lieb
1997 Kevin Daly
1998 Danny Parkin
1999 Chris Gbandi
2000 Chris Gbandi
2001 Chris Gbandi
2002 Chris Wingert
2003 Chris Wingert
2004 Jack Stewart
2005 Julius James
2006 Julius James
2007 Julius James
2008 Joel Gustafsson
2009 Kwame Watson-Siriboe
2009 Phil Edginton
2010 Austin Berry
2011 Andrew Jean-Baptiste