AFA Cup | Champion

1884-1885 Kearney Clarks ONT
1885-1886 Kearney Clarks ONT
1886-1887 Kearney Clarks ONT
1887-1888 Fall River Rovers
1888-1889 Fall River Rovers
1889-1890 Fall River Olympics
1890-1891 Fall River East Ends
1891-1892 Fall River East Ends
1892-1893 Pawtucket Free Wanderers
1893-1894 Pawtucket Olympics
1894-1895 Newark Caledonian
1895-1896 Paterson True Blues
1896-1897 Philadelphia Manz
1897-1898 Kearny Arlington
1905-1906 West Hudson AA
1906-1907 Kearney Clarks ONT
1907-1908 West Hudson AA
1908-1909 Paterson True Blues
1909-1910 Disston
1910-1911 Howard & Bullough
1911-1912 West Hudson AA
1912-1913 Paterson True Blues
1913-1914 Bethlehem Steel
1914-1915 Kearny Scots
1915-1916 Bethlehem Steel
1916-1917 Bethlehem Steel
1917-1918 Bethlehem Steel
1918-1919 Bethlehem Steel
1919-1920 Robins Dry Dock
1920-1921 Robins Dry Dock
1922-1923 Fleisher Yarn
1923-1924 Bethlehem Steel